Before Manual J load calculations were required and considered the standard for designing HVAC systems, most contractors would just take an educated guess as to what the system size should be. This approach to system design actually worked because they would be careful not to under size the system—which is important when considering that 75% of systems operating today are oversized. It is also well known that an oversized system:
- Uses more energy
- Does not dehumidify
- Will require more repairs
- Won’t last as long
- And will not provide the same comfort as a properly sized system.
Why a Manual J without a Manual D Is a Manual Mistake!
Now that the importance of a load calculation is understood, most contractors will perform a Manual J—but will they also perform a Manual D? And if they don’t how will the system work?
A Manual J calculates the exact BTU’s lost or gained thru the walls, roofs, and floors of a house. If the calculation finds a house gains 24,000 BTU, then we install a 24,000 BTU air conditioner in the house. Simple, right? The problem is that since we sized the system properly, we need to get 24,000 BTU out of that air conditioner and to do that, the ducts must be sized properly. Airflow x temperature difference = BTU, so if the airflow is not enough then then the BTU’s won’t be enough.
Manual D is used to design the duct work in a house and is part of the Manual J calculation process. Just like the Manual J determines exact BTUs, the Manual D calculation determines exact airflow; both are critical for the system to operate properly. If the duct system is not designed properly, not only will the system be inefficient, but it won’t cool the house or individual rooms.
An HVAC contractor can take an educated guess and use his own experience to design the duct, just like he could take an educated guess to pick the system size. But to use a Manual J to pick the system size and then guess at the duct design is a recipe for disaster—it just won’t work! In fact, it would be better to go back to the old way and not do a Manual J calculation at all.
Michael Bonsby HVAC Always Performs Manual J Calculations – and Manual D Calculations Too!
At Michael Bonsby Heating & Air Conditioning, all of our HVAC technicians are fully trained and experienced in performing Manual J calculations, along with Manual D calculations, to ensure our customers’ HVAC systems are properly sized. Ineffective sizing can impact the performance and efficiency of your HVAC equipment for its entire lifespan. Contact us for more information or to install your new heating and cooling systems the right way in Maryland or Washington, DC!